I believe Czaban was highly judgmental and disapproved not just of Darlie and her lifestyle, but rather had nothing but contempt for the modern American way in general. It was the same with the blonde hair and Daisy Duke outfits and flashy jewelry. Everyone seems to have a theory as to how it got there. I think every last juror saw every last one of those pictures. This case is unlike any other case that I have covered, because technically it's a solved case. That plan was still in place on the night of the murders, although it certainly raises the possibility that the men got the date wrong and were counting on the house being empty. Patterson. On the stand, Bevel testified that the mixture was actually the result of two separate occurrences, Darlie's blood having landed on the shirt first and then Damon's blood landing on the exact same spot of the shirt on top of Darlie's (or vice versa). Darlie Routier with Damon (left) and Devon (right). He was treated, evaluated, and it was determined that he was not a serious suicide risk. There were no lies in those letters, only misinformation. Investigators (and guilters) claim that Darlie's bloody footprints under the broken glass on the floor is further evidence of a staged crime scene. Their notes, however, told a different story. So here's my challenge to you: Find me proof of such a crime. I'm not saying it's impossible for his kicking to have caused that bruising, but it is improbable. One thing guilters love to say is, "Read the transcripts. Steve Cooper has known about this evidence for many years but that maggot has not got Texas to look at it. JustinCase976 (author) on December 16, 2019: You may very well be right. You can believe that or not, but I have an email from Bryce Benjet acknowledging their involvement. The biggest discrepancy was that the article cited Greg Davis as the attorney who cross-examined Darlie, when in reality, it was actually Toby Shook. That's funny, Laurie! Did you see my comment about the kitchen sink clean up ? I honestly have no idea. If the California lab, after comparing the many blood samples to the DNA profiles of the Routier family, determines that a foreign eligible profile has turned up, that sample is to be sent to Acadiana Criminalistics Laboratory in Iberia Parish, La., to determine if it matches the profile of anyone in the national DNA database. JustinCase976, please do not be fooled by all of these fake profiles. A lot of people doubt that Darin was actually planning a burglary scam; they say he just made that up to help with Darlie's appeal. No more so than the idea of Darlie as the killer, in my opinion. And this is the time when you told her to do that? There are those that steadfastly claim she could have feasibly done it, but it's just too much of a reach, as far as I'm concerned. Blood under glass & vacuum. JustinCase976 (author) on December 10, 2019: Vanessa Potkin and Bryce Benjet of the NY Innocence Project are indeed involved in her case. It's tempting to assume that's what we would have said in her position. The detectives were not called by the state to testify; it was the defense that put them on the stand. The two boys both died, but she was . Question: If the police officer committed perjury like you say, why hasn't the conviction been overturned? There was the dna of a black man found at the scene. DNA testing not available at the time was recently conducted and the results are discussed in the special. This time, he looked out the window and saw Darin running from the front yard, past the fountain and to the sidewalk, yelling, "Someone just stabbed my wife and kids!". DUH. One sticking point has been the DNA evidence. JustinCase976 (author) on August 22, 2019: Thanks for your comment, Fern; it's always nice to hear another standpoint from a supporter of Darlie's innocence. Question: What information does AFIS hold? In fact, a trauma nurse named Teresa Powers had provided lead detective Jimmy Patterson with an affidavit. You don't think its at all suspicious how her story kept changing? Who is Teresa Powers, and what is in that affidavit that Davis so desperately wanted to keep out? It was one of the attorneys that shared with me the detail of the frog planter. C'mon Justin, you really asking me how I know about the frog planter? The print is then scanned and entered into the system. Ive read a lot about this case. Since when does rage have to be personal? Somethings up. Okay. There could be any number of reasons why blood could have appeared to be wiped away, but please don't expect me to believe that an actively bleeding woman made a half-hearted attempt to clean up blood and then just gave up. Darlie, who doesn't know what to do, is simply doing as she has been instructed. JustinCase976 (author) on February 28, 2020: I didn't know that but that definitely raises an eyebrow. Q. At first she insisted there were no audio tapes; later she recanted and admitted that there were audio tapes, locked in a storage unit. Guilters like to note that her first priority was setting the stage of a break-in when it should have been requesting medical help for her children. In the early morning hours of June 6, 1996, 911 dispatchers in Rowlett, Texas received a panicked call from 26-year-old Darlie Routier. Additional DNA tests ordered for Routier I guess we'll know soon if Darlie is indeed innocent. Their mother, Darlie Routier, 26, slept on the couch. The dog was sound asleep, snoring away and dreaming of milk bones. Unfortunately, there is very little information available regarding Potter's affidavit and the circumstances leading up to her filing it. It's a small thing, but it's just one more detail that was used to make her look guilty, but which turned out to be completely untrue. Within 20 minutes, he decided that the crime scene was staged and the perpetrator was someone in the house. The Routiers had tickets to fly to Pennsylvania and were planning to fly out the following week, on the 14th. He never submitted a report, becauseyou guessed ithe was instructed not to. I have never believed this crime was personal; I think the attackers saw an opportunity to make a quick buck, believed the house was empty, and when they realized it wasn't, it all went bad. Her wounds were superficial & she didn't know what/where carotid was. Then they come up missing? The prosecution asserted that Darlie had enough time to commit the murders, run 75 yards down the alley to deposit the sock daubed with Devon's and Damon's blood, run back to the house, slash her throat, inflict her other injuries, and stage the scene. Twelve days later, on June 18, 1996, Darlie was arrested. WowI never really considered the possibility that perhaps Darin arranged it so that the "burglars" would come in when the family was in the house. I can understand her anger and frustration at yet another violation of privacy. I thank you for the compliment; I make every effort to be as accurate and detail oriented as possible. When he told her, she openly challenged him and asked if that was illegal. They are not replacing her current counsel in any way, they are simply supplementing their efforts at this point. Attorneys for Routier, including Smith and J. Stephen Cooper of Dallas, Richard Burr of Houston and Jane Pucher and Vanessa Potkin of the Innocence Project, all agreed to the procedure as outlined by the judge. He did not have a conversation with her; she was already at the hospital when he got to the house. To eliminate this problem, they simply brought the dog into their room every night when they went to bed. Now, for all you Supermoms out there who claim you would have been holding him in your arms: you need to remember that Damon had been stabbed in the back. The CPR is taking place in the Roman room (family room, den, whatever you want to call it), which is toward the back of the house, past the kitchen area. Wonder where they went? Bill Gorsuch was a neighbor who lived across the street and worked nights. Although the medical examiner found this to be highly suspicious, in the end, his death was classified as a suicide. Many people believe the call itself is a huge indication of Darlie's guilt, but that's strictly a matter of perception and open to interpretation. Bedrooms: 3. It's not like she was just standing there, chit-chatting with her girlfriends on the phone. Quinncy was able to meet with Karen while she was incarcerated at the Lubbock County Jail. According to Karen, in early June of 1996, Arkansas, Dwayne, and a third man "got into a fight about drugs" and took a road trip headed for Dallas in a stolen white truck. Answer: According to my research, witness perjury alone would not be enough to overturn the conviction. Look at the sketch of the first floor above to see exactly where the print was lifted. Two police officers were asked if they saw it on the kitchen floor. If you have seen this image in connection with Darlie Routier, you have been grossly misled. That is NOT in Kathy's book and is not common knowledge, so I was taken aback to see that particular comment. False. As you can see, the child went nowhere near the coffee table where the print was located. Did the Court get this one right? Have they taken her case or what? Would Darlie walk? Then she saw Damon was still moving, so she stabbed him a couple more times for good measure, knocked over the vacuum, broke a glass, and then screamed for Darin while running to call 911. She has also been widely criticized for not calling the police that night. Guilters will say that Darlie attacked the boys, and then ran down the alleyway to plant the sock before running back to the house, seeing Damon was still alive and moving around, and then stabbing him again before inflicting her own injuries. However, Officer David Mayne, who was responsible for the collection of evidence at the crime scene, used the phrase "I'm not for sure" 48 times during his cross-examination, and "I don't recall" exactly 25 times, for a whopping total of 73 times. Q. He reiterated the time during cross-examination, and was adamant that his clock is set for the actual, precise time, and not a few minutes fast as some people are prone to do. My response to that: "Only if you completely ignore everything presented by the defensewhich only a fool would do.". Because of what happened to that woman in Texas. Q. Dideverything she told you, did she tell you that before Sergeant Walling arrived? The location of the vacuum cleaner was another detail that caused investigators to suspect staging. Really, Alan? Charles Linch, a trace evidence analyst, testified that the bread knife from the kitchen was used to cut the screen. It is a minute, pinprick DOT. I knew Darin liked his nose candy, but never heard anything about meth use. So then they went to plan B and used a hunting knife to slice open the screen. Darlie is where she belongs. Still, Karl had nothing to gain by telling this story. He testified that on the morning of June 6, 1996, he had just settled into bed and drifted off when his sleep was broken by some kind of noise or commotion. The ambulance that was directly in front of Walling parked along a curve on Eagle Drive, across from the Routier's house and directly underneath where Gorsuch was standing. I believe I did read somewhere that this psychic told Darlie that a woman had done it, a woman who was supposedly very jealous of Darlie. So..1993 they buy the house and hes already doing an insurance scam with BJs daughter . ? I don't believe the glass broke when it hit the floor. There are a multitude of problems with the police investigation, the prosecution's case against Darlie, and the resulting conviction. I can understand the theory you have although, just like EPSTEIN DIDNT KILL HIMSELF.. there are so many coincidences ???? They found DNA from a black male on the sock found in the ally. As for comforting Damon: she tells him more than once to "Hang on honey, we're calling honey!" In all fairness, the birth of three children along with nursing did take its toll on Darlie's body. So many questions too many coincidences. He testified that he repeatedly instructed Darlie to put towels on Damon while he was standing right beside her; why do we not hear him say this on the 911 tape? The implants were a gift from Darin. Even the state's expert witnesses conceded that an intruder may not necessarily have tracked blood while making his exit. When someone comes up with a cover story, they've usually got their details in order before they start talking. Good point about Darins pants. Had Bevel been on the other side of the case, I firmly believe Tolle would have ruled differently. Now, was this during the time that you said that you wanted Mrs. Routier to administer first aid. HubPages is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Do you set yours rightI bet you set yours right on the money, don't you? But it may not have to go that far. Her husband, Darin, according to court documents, was asleep with the couples newborn in an upstairs bedroom. There is no way that bruising was caused by a 46 pound child kicking at her. In part 1 we discuss the crime scene, the injuries, and blood evidence. A. I assumed it was two to three or four minutes, somewhere in that area. The whole attack happened in a matter of minutes, and wasn't necessarily as noisy as some may assume. So Darin suspects Barbara Jovell or is this maid someone who is unnamed? That's actually in Kathy Cruz's book. Q. Did they ever recover the missing tapes of Sandra Halsey? This time, one of them had what appeared to be a screwdriver or knife. Darlie's blood was found to have dripped onto it, and there were wheel marks where it appeared the vacuum had been rolled through wet blood. I think if Darlie and Rebecca chuckled at her when she leaped to "save the baby" it was due to the melodramatic manner she displayed. She was found guilty of murdering 5-year-old Damon but never tried in the death of her 6-year-old son Devon. In truth, Darlie did not pick the music and did not know the song would be played, but the jury did not hear this. IMO. Did Sergeant Walling ever tell her to administer first aid? According to the prosecution, Darlie cut her own throat while standing at the sink, and then attempted to clean it up. The bottom line is, I feel that Czaban's entire testimony should be taken with a pillar of salt. Nothing new in the DNA. Groggy and confused, Darlie instinctively followed the man through her kitchen toward the utility room that leads out to a garage. What if the baby woke up and Darin had to come down and warm up a bottle? He loved to cut things and show off with his knife. I believe it ALL happened. The case of Darlie Routier is controversial and has the support of the innocence project. That changed when I read Dateline Purgatory: Examining the Case That Sentenced Darlie Routier To Death by Kathy Cruz. The belief is that Darlie grabbed a wine glass from out of the wine rack and tossed it on the floor to make it look like there was a struggle. TWELVE DAYS! Home Uncategorized darlie routier dna results 2021 Uncategorized darlie routier dna results 2021 Reminds me of that scene in My Cousin Vinny: Judge: Mr. Gambini, that was a lucid, intelligent, well thought out objection. You can say whatever you want about Mary Rickels and her story of the two men that tried to break in her house, but I have seen Arkansas's mugshot, and one of the men she described fits him to a T. The description of the other man very closely fits Dwayne. It may go a long way with regard to getting her a new trial, but even that is not a given. ", Karen said, "They said they broke into a house and it all went bad. All right. Q. Q. She had written letters to friends and family members while in jail, and these letters were read by jail officials, copied, and sent to the prosecution. It is known that Darin did go outside to get help from Karen Neal, another neighbor across the street who happened to be a nurse. It didn't just magically appear, and regardless of what some fools say, it is NOT Darlie's print, or anyone else who was known to be in the house. Some people swear they have, other people say it's a load of crap. I stepped over, to look into the garage, just to see if I could see anybody, and told her to apply some pressure to the first child's wounds. Just my theory. In another, she has no memory of fighting with him. I agree completely. This whole case reeks of corruption! How did the glass get on top of those bloody footprints? Still, I'd love to know how his bloody jeans managed to end up in a pile of clean, folded laundry. He attempted to hang himself in his cell, but was not successful. 6) I'm not even going to argue about the letters. I believe he took that chance just as Waddell was pulling up. Darlie Routier has been on death row for five years now, always insisting that she didn't kill her sons Devon and Damon. Find a record of young children that were stabbed during a home invasion that took place within a 50-mile radius of Dallas during that time frame, and then maybe I'll budge on my stance that Darlie is innocent. Police almost immediately focused on Routier, who was sleeping in a downstairs television room with the children. What do four of the world's top body language, behavior, and interrogation experts weigh in their personal opinions on behavior w. Mary Rickels eye yi yi Re: Darlene Potter, I could understand remembering the day I pulled a big trailer from my daughters. She is not concerned about her own prints being on that knife; it's her knife, from her own kitchen. There's just too many variables. I don't see where either Darren or Darlie ever said that. I can picture Marybeth Tinning holding a pillow over her infant's faces again and again and again. Why, it's all RELATIVE, of course. Pleading the 5th amendment seemed to be a recurring theme in this trial. Seen lotsa ER people looking neat for the unplanned visit. They also stated that had Darlie been acquitted of Damon's murder, they could have then charged her with Devon's murder, doubling their chances of a convictionhmmm, perhaps their case was not as strong as they would like us to believe? The purpose of this database is to link crimes to other crimes and offenders. Still, Rickels did not call 911. Darlie was home alone with the kids every day. It's part of an all-out push by the Innocence Project to . They could not have an unsolved double homicide of two young children and the general public panicking about a lunatic on the loose. Okay. Oh, C. George, there's so many things I wish I could say! I just can't buy the idea that Darlie was the one who murdered her kids. Hmmmm. Of course, she didn't do that, because she knew full well the baby was fine. Q. As for the accomplices that were with Tim Harris, if they get one of them to talk, I bet that they will throw Harris directly under the bus. He trusted BJ / daughter Enough back then. and even Darlie knew the maid/friend whatever was smokin weed. theres your drug connection. years of it. It fell off when bandage removed. In early 1998, Karl was in jail reading The New Yorker magazine when he came upon an article about the impending execution of Karla Faye Tucker. I scoured the documents with a fine tooth comb looking for the answer to that question. A liar already has their story prepared in their mind. She was in and out of consciousness, and for the time that she was conscious, she would have been in fight-or-flight mode. How did you know about that??? Internal job & corruption = recipe for a death row disaster. I think she was a bit of a drama queen that made a big deal out of absolutely nothing. She turned on the porch light and the men ran off. A videotape of a graveside birthday celebration for Darlie's late son showed Darlie smiling, chewing gum, and spraying "silly string" while singing "Happy Birthday.". Dekleva examined Darlie and came to the conclusion that she was not a sociopath; nor did she, in his opinion, present a future danger to society, one of the main criteria used to determine eligibility for the death penalty. So, it was 2:40 you're telling us? I'm sorry, but it just doesn't wash. One replied that he did not; the other replied he remembered seeing it, but wasn't sure if it was there when he first came in or if it was later when he did a walk through. They were old mug shots that were shared with me privately by an attorney, and I don't believe they can be found on any website. Rickels peered out the blinds and saw that the men had returned and were trying to get in the window. For me, Im so excited!!!!!! Sponges and cleaning products beneath the sink were inspected, and not a drop of blood was found on either. Darlie's story was also featured. The bloody sock in the alleyway had not even been discovered at this point. As the man made his escape, he dropped a large butcher knife onto the floor. I have to agree with you that he would not have taken the time to put on his jeans if he truly heard things breaking and Darlie screaming. Because it couldn't be matched to anyone elseand with Cron's statement that it "could" be a juvenile printit suddenly became proof positive that Damon must have left that fingerprint. So riddle me this: How is it possible that Darin can make it all the way through the house, out the front door, into the yard, wait for Waddell to get out of the police car, walk up to him, and ask him to identify himselfin the span of 12 seconds? Q. I will never believe that he actually stabbed Darlie or the kids, nor do I believe he hired people to kill his family. The officer, of course, is Matt Walling. The 2021 DNA came back with "foreign eligible profile" has turned up, that sample is to be sent to Acadiana Criminalistics Laboratory in Iberia Parish, La., to determine if it matches the profile of anyone in the national DNA database. I did point this out in a comment, but the author chose not to publish the comment. In the letter, Karl, who was then incarcerated at The Potter County Jail, described an argument he had heard between two other inmates in late fall of 1996 as they were coming in from the rec yard. As anyone who is familiar with this case already knows, the original transcripts contained over 33,000 errors. Linch was instructed by the prosecution team to avoid recording his findings in a written report. The blood we see is mostly Darlie's, and it wasn't shed until after she stood up and began walking around. She told me that she had fought with somebody in the kitchen area, and that after she fought with him he had ran out into the garage and dropped the knife somewhere in the kitchen, between the kitchen and the garage, and that she had went and picked up the knife, and laid it on the counter, which was, she pointed to the counter, and the knife was sitting there. They'll say he did it all and they didn't hurt anybody. DNA evidence in her case is being tested this. I'm open-minded and always willing to consider new evidence, but at this point I don't feel as though anything that happened that night was planned. State's exhibit 85-J, the unidentified fingerprint found in blood at the crime scene, was recently uploaded into the system after years of fighting. Arkansas had also requested to see a psychiatrist while in jail, as he claimed he was suffering from nightmares and flashbacks related to one of his past crimes. Personally, I would lean more toward there being a middle man from Rowlett or nearby that set this whole thing up. DLR should easily be released. Now, when I look at the pictures of the sink, I see: the left side, the right side, and the front. Why do they have to do that if they're so confident in her guilt? Darlie Routier - Part 1 Posted on May 15, 2022 by brandyanne2 Darlie Routier is sitting on death row for killing her two young boys, although she has only been officially charged with one of their murders. But Judge Tolle overrode this. The defense wanted to put Mr. Harrell on the stand to bring this discrepancy to the attention of the jury. The print could only have been left while the blood was still wet, meaning that whoever left it was present at the time of the murders. In order for blood to be under the glass, Darlie would have to be bleeding before she tossed the glass onto the ground, right? JustinCase976 (author) on December 14, 2019: I honestly haven't seen any evidence that this housekeeper had anything to do with what happened. There were also cleaning supplies kept under the sink. Darlie Routier cannot be excluded as the contributor of the DNA from 10-2589-502. A dog will only bark at an intruder if the dog is aware of his presence. The prosecution team was very good at setting the stage and creating the character of "Darlie the Killer." And that Mr Mayhem was invited over. In the event that Darlie is fully exonerated, I guess it would be up to the DA's office whether or not they have enough evidence to pursue charges. I predict that the first one to talk will get immunity. Look at all the red spots that indicate where Damon went in the family room. Her husband, Darin, and seven-month-old son Drake were asleep in an upstairs bedroom, unharmed. There is 100% proof that Darlie was drugged the night of the murders. The circle indicates this is Devon's blood on the back of Darlie's night shirt. Waddell testified that when he first pulled up to the house, he saw a man (Darin Routier) coming out of the front door into the yard. Keep in mind, Darlie is on the phone with 911 and Darin is attempting to perform CPR on Devon, who is not breathing. How can the crime scene and evidence be expected to match her story when she can provide part of the narrative? Your dad loves you all very much and I know in my heart he will take care of my babies. It was kind of hard to miss. If they do, my bet is that is that someone is going to end up taking a deal from prosecutors. Routier has always claimed a stranger had broken into the home and killed the kids . As if Rickels' testimony wasn't enough for reasonable doubt, we also have the affidavit filed by Darlene Potter.
Who Will Be My Future Husband Astrology, Navarino Orchard Picking Schedule, Tortoisegit Not Showing On Right Click, Samsung Odyssey G40b Speakers Not Working, The Forms Of Capital Bourdieu Summary, 2023 Biweekly Payroll Calendar Generator, Fatal Car Accident Barry County, Mi,
